Im not knocking the quality of comedy in that movie, nor am I biased cause Im a fur (read on I do something surprising) but seriously, Khale would seem to be the best choice in this dont ya think? I mean this was best movie, and that was the best movie. Best quality, best animated, and the voices were unique. There she is was good, but I understand it losing out cause its more a music video then anything else. A walk in the woods I can understand losing as well just given what we are comparing it too, but if they chose the best moive based on comedy, then wining over pancakes is a lie.
THE PANCAKES ARE A LIE
But seriously Chucks new tux was beat out by two movies on two diffrent fronts. How it won is beyond me, but hell I dont have a popular site that you can submit shit to do I?
SO TOM, I SAY TO THEE: Delete thy Pico 2, and look out for me when that Lit portal gets up.
VACKenny
The Story of Khale suffers from something called Fallen Angel Syndrome; it's when its hype is driven by one or two really strong teasers/trailers, but the actual episode itself does little to nothing.
I mean, what happens in Khale? Wakes up, takes a bath, spars with his... brother, I think, eats, and goes to some school... but there's no plot. It's all art. I'm not calling it bad, it's just that Chuck's New Tux had more plot than Khale, and more people would watch that again than Khale.
To top it all off, so much effort is placed into Khale that we really won't see any episodes until a year later, maybe even longer. Happy Harry really knew how to dedicate his time and not only churned out Chuck's New Tux, but a handful of other great toons in a similar time frame.
The Pancakes short was an even better contender than Khale considering the material and an actual plot, but Chuck's New Tux was fast paced and practically indistinguishable from an actual cartoon.
/opinion
TheReno
Ill conceed the point on khale, but Pancakes drew you in before the ultimate punch line, Chuck was just I have a tux and akl;dhsfnl;ajknhkl;jbfak;jabk;fjb dead.